Dussel Now: The Transmodern Alternative

Frederick B. Mills · Orinoco Tribune, November 3, 2021

This essay introduces Enrique Dussel’s philosophy of liberation as a critical-ethical framework for decolonial thought and action, and as an invitation to further study. It argues that Dussel’s transmodern alternative is urgently relevant now. Many people today accept the existing order as “the way things are” and treat suffering of the excluded, the poor, those under sanctions and victims of war and genocide as someone else’s problem.

The argument in brief

Where it comes from. The philosophy of liberation emerged in Latin America in the late 1960s, alongside the anti-imperial struggles of the time. Dussel traces modernity back to the conquest of the Americas and the African slave trade, and he exposes the Eurocentric reasoning used to justify them.

Beyond modernity, not against reason. Transmodernity is neither a reform of modernity nor postmodern relativism. It is committed to shared ethical principles, above all the promotion of human life in community and in harmony with nature. It also draws on critical theory, discourse ethics and Marx, and values the cultures negated and suppressed by colonialism. Its goal is a pluriverse, in the Zapatistas’ words a world in which many worlds fit.

How ethical consciousness awakens. Following Levinas, Dussel holds that we have a pre-reflective sensibility to the suffering of others. The face-to-face encounter with victims of the prevailing system can reawaken it, while propaganda that dehumanizes whole groups can dull it. The path runs from naive acceptance of the system to critical awareness and collective action. Rigoberta Menchú’s testimony illustrates it.

Totality and the Other. Dussel’s “totality” is a totalizing system that claims to be the whole, but it is never closed. People always exceed the roles the system assigns them. Starting from those it excludes, his analectic method makes the system itself an object of critique and opens a breach of resistance within it.

Three principles and a politics. Dussel’s ethics rests on three principles that condition one another: the material principle (produce and develop life), the formal principle (democratic agreement among all affected) and the principle of feasibility. In politics, power is legitimate only when delegated institutions (potestas) obey the constituent power of the people (potentia). Mexico’s “Fourth Transformation,” though imperfect, since AMLO, serves as a current example.

The essay closes with Martin Luther King Jr.’s image of a “World House.” Liberation is a shared, unfinished project of decolonizing minds and transforming institutions towards a transmodern horizon.

Key concepts

  • Transmodernity: moving beyond Eurocentric modernity while keeping universal ethical principles in pluriversal form.
  • Analectic method: critique that starts from the excluded Other, outside the system’s pretense to a universal ideology.
  • Totality and alterity: the dominant system (“the Same”) and the Other it excludes
  • Pre-originary ethical rationality: the pre-reflective sensibility to another’s suffering from which ethics is awakened
  • Proxemia and proximidad: nearness to things versus face-to-face nearness to persons
  • Potentia and potestas: the constituent power of the people and the delegated power of institutions

Read the full essay

Cite this essay

Mills, Frederick B. 2021. “Dussel Now: The Transmodern Alternative.” Orinoco Tribune, November 3, 2021. https://orinocotribune.com/dussel-now-the-transmodern-imperative-essay/.

Related